

Paolo Domenico Finoglio
(Orta di Atella or Naples, c. 1590 – Conversano, 1645)
The Mass of Saint Philip Neri
1635.
Oil on canvas, 218 x 158 cm.
N.R. 200.183. Acquired in Naples in 1919.
In May 1919, after World War I had ended, Abbot Marcet traveled once again to Rome and Naples, taking the opportunity as on previous occasions to purchase paintings for Montserrat. This time, the Neapolitan acquisitions were The Adoration of the Shepherds by Stomer and The Mass of Saint Philip Neri, which arrived at Montserrat in September of that year; the painting of Saint Philip Neri with the note of auctor ignotus, as published in Montserrat's culture journal Analecta Montserratensia, III, 1919, p. 389. In Fr. Gusi's inventories from the 1930s and 1940s, it appears as "17th-century Spanish school," and the 1956 1956 Artistic Index of Montserrat lists it as attributed to the Valencian Jeroni Jacint Espinosa. As it was a devotional painting by an unknown author, this work was not featured in the public museum in 1963 and remained inside the monastery, albeit always in prominent locations.
Alfonso Pérez Sánchez did not include this painting in his study of 17th-century Italian painting in Spain, and the first scholar to pay attention to it and highlight its value was the Roman professor Liliana Barroero, who immediately and without hesitation attributed it to the Neapolitan Paolo Domenico Finoglio. Barroero's proposal has been accepted without difficulty and corroborated by other Italian specialists who have inspected the work. The grounds making this attribution credible rest on the resemblance of our painting to other works by Finoglio, such as The Virgin with Saint Teresa and Saint Joseph in the Neapolitan church of Santa Maria Donnaromita and the Madonna with Saints Bernardino, Margaret, and Anthony Abbot in Fonseca (Naples)—both reproduced in Spinosa's book Civiltà del Seicento a Napoli—as well as Saint Peter Consecrating Saint Aspren as Bishop in Pozzuoli Cathedral. All three works should be dated around 1635, coinciding with our Saint Philip Neri.
Liliana Barroero highlights the remarkable parallel between the Madonna in the Fonseca canvas and the one appearing in the upper right corner of The Mass of Saint Philip Neri, both in terms of the facial features and the posture of the Child. The similarities between the Saint Teresa painting and ours appear above all in the heads of the little angels and in the rich fabric of the cloak with which Saint Joseph covers the saint—very similar, if not identical, to that of the red chasuble worn by our Saint Philip. But the affinities are even closer and more evident with the large painting in Pozzuoli Cathedral, affecting the overall composition, lighting, physiognomies, and the most noticeable details of the pleating of the saint's alb and the acolytes' surplices.
Our canvas belongs to Finoglio's final period in Naples, representing the maturity of his creativity shortly before relocating permanently to Conversano (Bari) at the invitation of Count Giangirolamo II Acquaviva d’Aragona. Given its dimensions and layout, it must have been an altarpiece (pala d’altare), as Barroero suggests and as are the three major reference paintings reviewed. Its iconography derives from the painting commissioned in 1614 from Guido Reni (1575–1642) by the Fathers of the Oratory in Rome on the occasion of the beatification of Saint Philip. Reni's painting became the prototype for a series with numerous variations, or for countless copies frequently executed from prints. Nevertheless, almost all these paintings inspired by Reni's work retain the fundamental features: the exact physiognomy of the saint faithfully preserved through drawings and paintings made during his lifetime, his kneeling posture, the priestly vestments featuring a fine red chasuble in honor of the Holy Spirit and in memory of the grace of the enlargement of his heart during Pentecost in 1544, and the apparition of the Virgin manifesting her favor.
Guido Reni paints a static Saint Philip Neri against a neutral, hazy background; Finoglio, by contrast, stages the scene at the moment when the saint has just finished saying Mass, surrounded by angel-winged acolyte boys carrying the relevant liturgical instruments. The boy in the foreground prepares to extinguish the candles with a snuffer; the one behind offers the saint his biretta to cover his head now that the Mass has ended, as prescribed; the two in the background to the viewer's right carry the censer, the cruets, and the boat; and in the center foreground on the floor, the artist has placed an embossed silver holy water sprinkler.
Finoglio has not yet been the subject of a systematic study and was usually regarded as a minor painter in the splendid firmament of Neapolitan Baroque, where stellar figures like Cavallino, Stanzione, or Caracciolo shone. The 2012 retrospective exhibition in Conversano (Bari) cast new light on this author and reinforced his stature, which Nicola Spinosa had already pointed out three decades earlier.
Our painting was acquired with an unsympathetic restoration featuring unfortunate retouchings that affect the face of the angel in the background and other areas. Modern restorations have not removed these heavy interventions, as the original paint layer has disappeared. This canvas has seen little external promotion, having participated only in the exhibition Salzillo, testigo de un siglo, curated by Dr. Cristóbal Belda Navarro at the Museo Salzillo in Murcia in 2007.
Josep de C. Laplana, Director of the Museum of Montserrat
Bibliography:
Nicola Spinosa, La pittura napoletana del ‘600, Milan, Longanesi, 1984, p. 272-273, fig.
Nicola Spinosa, Civiltà dei Seicento a Napoli, Naples, Electa Napoli, 1984, vol I, fig. 361.
Liliana Barroero, “Schede seicentesche: Fignolio, Vaccaro, Vanni e il Maestro degli Annunci”, Prospettiva, IV-1989 – X-1990, no. 57-60, vol. II, p. 217-221.
Liliana Barroero, Dipinti italiani dal XV al XIX secolo del Museo di Montserrat, Rome, Istituto Poligrafico e Zecca dello Stato. Libreria della Stato, 1992, p. 47-49. fig.
La regola e la fama. San Filippo Neri e l’arte, exhibition catalog, Sopraintendenza per i Beni Artistici e Storici, Rome, Palazzo Venezia, X-XII-1995, Milan, Electa, 1995, p. 535-536 (Olga Malasecchi).
Dizionario Biogràfico degli Italiani, 48, 1997, s/v. Finoglio, Paolo Domenico, p. 70 (Valentina Antonucci).
Josep de C. Laplana, Les col·leccions de pintura de l’Abadia de Montserrat, Publicacions de l’Abadia de Montserrat, 1999, p. 37, 43, fig.
Cristóbal Belda Navarro, Salzillo, testigo de un siglo, Murcia, Museu Salzillo, 2007, p. 108, fig.




Les cookies són importants per a tu, influeixen en la teva experiència de navegació, ens ajuden a protegir la teva privacitat i permeten realitzar les peticions que ens sol·licitis a través de la web. Utilitzem cookies pròpies i de tercers per analitzar els nostres serveis i mostrar-te publicitat relacionada com les teves preferències en base a un perfil elaborat amb els teus hàbits de navegació. Pots "Acceptar" o "Rebutjar" aquelles cookies que no siguin tècniques, així com també configurar les teves preferències prement "Configurar Cookies". Per a més informació, consulta la nostra Política de Cookies.