

Anonymous Italian painter of the mid-17th century
Roman Charity (Cimon and Pero).
Oil on canvas, 121 x 97 cm.
N.R. 200.157. Acquired in Rome in 1917.
The Roman historian Valerius Maximus (late 1st century BC – AD 31) in his book Factorum et dictorum memorabilium libri IX, IV, 4, De pietate in parentes, relates the touching exemplary story of the classical Pietas of a daughter named Pero, who secretly breastfed her father, the aged Cimon, sentenced to die of starvation in prison. Upon learning of the story, the Roman Senate released the prisoner. This captivating scene, which visually expresses the complete dependence of a frail, elderly father on his daughter, was a highly popular subject in literature, painting, and sculpture during the 16th and 17th centuries, free from any picaresque or licentious connotations.
In November 1916, Abbot Marcet traveled to Rome via Paris and visited the studio of art dealer Giuseppe Gonnella, the usual supplier of paintings for Montserrat. In his workshop he found the Roman Charity discussed here, in which he immediately displayed special interest. Fr. Ubach, acting in Rome as the abbot's agent in these matters, reproached him in a letter dated February 8, 1917: “I believe Your Paternity showed too much eagerness to own this painting right from the start. Having immediately agreed to the initial proposal of L. 6,000, now there are endless excuses being made to raise the price under various pretexts” (AAMt).
However, the sale could not be finalized as quickly as the abbot wished because one of the members of the owning family was at the war front. Eventually, this obstacle was resolved, and on August 15, 1917, Ubach explained to Abbot Marcet the difficulties in securing an export permit: “After many formalities, we have managed to clear the last paintings. The Charity in particular cost a great deal, because as an original work, it had to be declared at its value of L. 6,000—an amount exceeding L. 5,000 that significantly increased the permit and transport expenses. But it is of no consequence, as the painting is well worth the effort” (AAMt).
It should be noted that throughout the transaction proceedings, neither the dealer nor the buyer ever mentioned an author, referring only to the subject. Nevertheless, when the transaction was finalized, the owning family delivered a surviving document concerning this painting: a surprising expertise signed in 1846 by a group of Spanish painters residing in Rome. They attested that, in their qualified opinion, the canvas in question was an authentic work by “Bartolomeo Murillo, Pittore Spagnuolo e Capuscuola di Siviglio”. Its signatories were the Valencian academician Agustí Gimeno Bartual (1798–1853), the Aragonese sculptor Ponciano Ponzano (1813–1877), the Majorcan painter Benito Soriano Murillo (1827–1891), the Catalan Miquel Fluixench (1820–1894), the miniaturist Manuel Arbós Ayerbe (?—1875), and the Cuban Juan Jorge Peoli (1825–1893). Except for the Valencian artist, who was well over forty, all the rest were a group of young artists spending a period of academic training in Rome; for them, the document was likely nothing more than a playful prank to earn a few lire. The curious part is that nearly all these romantic-minded "fellows," little interested in objective analysis, went on to become notable figures in their respective specialties.
The painting arrived at Montserrat in the large shipment of December 1917 and was published with its image in Analecta Montserratensia under the note: “original attributed to Murillo”. As expected, however, this "romantic" attribution soon raised eyebrows among experts. Professor August Mayer of the Alte Pinakothek in Munich, after reviewing Montserrat's collection with a critical eye, wrote to Fr. Gusi on January 31, 1928: “The Roman Charity calls to mind works by Langetti” (AMMt). Giambattista Langetti (1625–1670) was a fully Baroque Genoese artist who passed through Naples and settled in Venice. In his inventories, Fr. Gusi, likely wishing to test the lead provided by Dr. Mayer, systematically recorded our canvas as "attributed" to Bernardo Strozzi (Genoa, 1581 – Venice, 1644). Yet he was uncertain. In his notebook he completely dismissed Murillo's authorship, noting: “It is more than certain that the author is Italian. Venetian school? Strozzi?... No serious research has been done on this painting, which may well be the most valuable in the entire collection” (AMMt).
In the early 1960s, when the Museum of Montserrat was organized and opened to the public, presenting a painting as "by an unknown hand" was considered undesirable. Thus, the canvas was exhibited under Strozzi's authorship and widely reproduced in tourist publications and postcards. Pérez Sánchez, in his 1965 study, finding no plausible attribution for this painting, simply ignored it. During a visit by Dr. Giovanni Previtali and Dr. José Milicua in September 1976, they affirmed that it was not by Strozzi, yet no other candidate came to mind, and the painting retained the label of Strozzi without ever being thoroughly studied.
The central question of authorship took a step forward—though likely not a final one—with Liliana Barroero's study. The problem was analyzed alongside her mentor, Professor Federico Zeri, and they considered that this work could be attributed alla cerchia di Nicolò Tornioli (Siena, 1598 – Rome, 1651). This virtually unknown Sienese painter, who learned from Rutilio Manetti in his homeland, worked in Rome within the circle of friends of the Oratorian Virgilio Spada (1596–1662), almoner to Pope Innocent X, an influential figure and patron of major projects. Zeri, who served as director and reorganizer of the Galleria Spada in Rome after the war—where the paintings acquired by Fr. Virgilio are preserved—found parallels between the Montserrat canvas and a work by Tornioli of the same subject in that Roman collection, as well as another from the same circle and subject at the Museum of Châteauroux.
Barroero's proposal, backed by Zeri's authority, appeared convincing, and the Museum updated the painting's attribution from Strozzi to Tornioli. Certainly, Zeri's suggestions were the most reasoned to date regarding our Roman Charity, but specialists quickly expressed general disagreement, and the new attribution continued to raise doubts. The conclusion we have reached is this: the canvas is exquisite and executed by a highly capable hand, an original beyond doubt, yet it remains a painting "in search of an author."
Josep de C. Laplana, Director of the Museum of Montserrat
Bibliography
Analecta Montserratensia, I, 1917, p. 337, fig.
Liliana Barroero, Dipinti italiani dal XV al XIX secolo del Museo di Montserrat, Rome, Istituto Poligrafico e Zecca dello Stato. Libreria della Stato, 1992, p. 60, fig.
Josep de C. Laplana, Les col·leccions de pintura de l’Abadia de Montserrat, Publicacions de l’Abadia de Montserrat, 1999, p. 120, fig.
Les cookies són importants per a tu, influeixen en la teva experiència de navegació, ens ajuden a protegir la teva privacitat i permeten realitzar les peticions que ens sol·licitis a través de la web. Utilitzem cookies pròpies i de tercers per analitzar els nostres serveis i mostrar-te publicitat relacionada com les teves preferències en base a un perfil elaborat amb els teus hàbits de navegació. Pots "Acceptar" o "Rebutjar" aquelles cookies que no siguin tècniques, així com també configurar les teves preferències prement "Configurar Cookies". Per a més informació, consulta la nostra Política de Cookies.