Artistic and archaeological heritage of the Abbey of Montserrat
Thursday, 19 November 2026

La Fontaine, by Hyacinthe Rigaud

Museum of Montserrat - EN 20 June 2014


Hyacinthe Rigaud and Workshop
(Perpignan, 1659 – Paris, 1743)
Portrait of the Fabulist Jean de La Fontaine
1690
Oil on canvas, 81 x 64 cm.
N.R. 200.250. Donation of Teresa Roy de Espallargas, widow of Georges de Frézals, 1927.
 
Georges de Frézals was a cultured aristocrat and bibliophile who, upon settling in Barcelona as consul of Belgium and France at the end of World War I, became a promoter of Catalan culture. In 1925, he made a substantial donation of books to the Montserrat library, and after his death, his widow completed the donation on her husband's behalf with a hundred more luxuriously bound books, as well as five canvases depicting members of his family, including portraits of La Fontaine and his wife Marie Héricart, painted respectively by Rigaud and Mignard. Frézals considered himself an heir to the famous French fabulist Jean de La Fontaine (1621–1695). The back of the canvas bears the following inscription: “Jean de La Fontaine fabuliste, peinté par Rigaud. Tableau procédant du chateau de Thury en Valois...”

The 2008 catalog Obras Maestras del Museo de Montserrat contains the most thoroughly documented study of our painting, written by Ariane James-Sarazin, which I hereby summarize. Hyacinthe Rigaud's account book for 1690 includes a portrait of La Fontaine for which the painter charged 200 livres, the standard price for a half-length portrait without hands. Three versions of similar dimensions exist that may correspond to this well-documented commission: the Montserrat version, rectangular in format, and two oval-format versions auctioned in Paris in 1990 and 1995; one of these found a permanent home at the Musée Carnavalet in Paris, while the other remains in private hands. All three versions are of exceptional quality and stand out among the half-dozen period copies from the first or second half of the 18th century. The portrait of La Fontaine painted by Rigaud in 1690 became famous and was engraved and widely reproduced in editions of the fabulist's works to the point of becoming the most widely circulated and recognizable image of the author, appearing in countless French literature textbooks.

The underlying question is determining which of the three versions is the prototype and which are the autograph copies or workshop replicas executed by Rigaud's many well-trained assistants, who also collaborated on original and major works by the master. Following the surviving documentation step by step, an inventory compiled in 1703 reveals that Rigaud kept a portrait of La Fontaine in his house, which could be a version or replica of the one delivered to the fabulist. This version was the one featured at the Louvre Salon in 1704 as part of a temporary exhibition of twenty-eight works by the artist. Another lead is a commission for a portrait of La Fontaine placed in 1704—likely prompted by the Louvre exhibition—by M. Coustard, inspector general of the chancery, to form part of a gallery of illustrious men of letters. This is almost certainly the version that ended up at the Musée Carnavalet in Paris. Nevertheless, these disquisitions are not of paramount importance, as all three works demonstrate the artist's personal hand.

The Montserrat painting holds an advantage by presenting a provenance directly tied to La Fontaine's heirs. We know that Viscount Héricart de Thury inherited this work from Louis-Christophe Anne Héricart de Thury, who in turn inherited it from Marie-Claire de La Fontaine, the writer's great-granddaughter, who died without issue. Thus, there is a very strong likelihood that it is indeed the 1690 prototype. Dominique Brême noted that when Rigaud painted this portrait, Jean de La Fontaine was already 69 years old, suggesting the idea that it might actually have been painted in 1684, when the writer entered the Académie Française, and that the entry in the 1690 account book refers to a replica. While this hypothesis is plausible, one must also remember that high-status portraiture always tends to soften and conceal overly visible marks of old age and decrepitude.

According to James-Sarazin's assessment, the Montserrat portrait of La Fontaine is slightly dryer than the Carnavalet version regarding the flesh tones, the wig, and the folds of the coat. The painter focused all his interest on the skeptical and disenchanted expression of the fabulist, who so deeply understood the recesses of the human heart and the accommodating reactions of human nature. The background is entirely neutral, and setting aside any showiness, he employed a very restrained palette of whites, blacks, grays, and browns, with which he succeeded in depicting the softness of the fabrics and the transparency of the cravat. The predominant notes of this portrait are elegant simplicity and complete truthfulness.

Montserrat's portrait of La Fontaine forms a pair with another depicting Marie Héricart, the writer's wife, of the same size and with the same framing, both originating from the Château de Thury and both donated by Georges de Frézals. The portrait of Marie Héricart arrived with an attribution to the painter Pierre Mignard (1612–1693), which Dominique Brême replaced with Gabriel Revel (1642–1712), and which Jean-Claude Boyer subsequently reattributed to Mignard. At the end of the Spanish Civil War in January 1939, both paintings were taken to France along with the rest of Montserrat's artistic heritage, but the French government returned them to Montserrat on October 28, 1939. Another episode occurred in 1943 when, at the instigation of Minister Serrano Suñer, the Marquess of Lozoya, Director General of Fine Arts, pressured the Abbot of Montserrat to perform an exchange—clearly disadvantageous to Montserrat—because the Spanish government wished to present a gift to the Vichy regime. Fortunately, at the last moment, the exchange was not carried out. Though often overlooked, this canvas is the only work in our country by this painter from Northern Catalonia, who shone with his own light at the court of the Sun King, the most splendid in Europe in his time.
 
Bibliography
Analecta Montserratensia, VII, 1927, p. 408, fig.
Perpignan, 1959, p. 12, no. 10, fig.
Raymond Josse, “Sur les portraits de Jean de La Fontaine et de sa femme à Montserrat”, Courrier des Chercheurs et de Curieux, suppléments du nº 240 de Miroir d’Histoire, 108, December, 1969, p. 371.
Jean de La Fontaine, exhibition catalog, Paris, Bibliothèque Nationale de France, Ed. Seuil, 1995; p. 108-121 (Dominique Brême).
Dominique Brême, Jean de La Fontaine (1621-1695). L’homme et son temps, exhibition catalog, Meaux, Musée Bossuet, 1995.
Josep de C. Laplana, Les col·leccions de pintura de l’Abadia de Montserrat, Publicacions de l’Abadia de Montserrat, 1999, p. 44 and 48, fig.
Obras Maestras del Museo de Montserrat en BBVA. De Caravaggio a Picasso.  
Exhibition catalog at the Palacio del Marqués de Salamanca, BBVA, Madrid, Oct 9 – Dec 7, 2008, p. 104-107, fig. (Ariane James-Sarazin). 

Tags
Classroom