Artistic and archaeological heritage of the Abbey of Montserrat
Thursday, 19 November 2026

Allegory of the Birth of Francis I of Austria

Museum of Montserrat - EN 25 June 2014


Giambattista Tiepolo
(Venice, 1696 – Madrid 1770)
Allegory of the Birth of Francis I of Austria
Between 1768 and 1770.
Oil on canvas, 46.5 x 57 cm.
N.R. 201.228. Donation Xavier Busquets, 1990.
 
This work arrived at the Museum of Montserrat as part of the testamentary bequest of architect Xavier Busquets. Previously, in 1976, he had acquired it at a Christie's auction in London for £36,000. It came from the Edoardo Ferreira Pinto-Basto collection and was a well-known piece in the academic world, having been examined and published in their monographs by such accredited specialists as Molmenti, Fiocco, Morassi, and Pallucchini. In the Christie's auction, it bore the title Chronos Entrusting Cupid to Venus, but Liliana Barroero, upon studying our painting and following Levey's analysis—which explains in full detail the subject and the occasion for which it was painted—changed its former title to the current, more accurate one: Allegoria per la nascita di Francesco I d’Austria.

Levey explains that Maria Luisa of Spain, daughter of Charles III of Spain and wife of Leopold of Habsburg, Grand Duke of Tuscany, gave birth in February 1768 to her firstborn, who was baptized with the name Francis. Given that Emperor Joseph II had no offspring, by dynastic law the newborn was destined to become Emperor of Austria. This is the event that prompted Tiepolo to paint this canvas which, according to Pallucchini, is not a preliminary sketch for a larger, definitive composition, but an artwork with its own intrinsic value, fully finished nello stile evocativo, più che descrittivo ("in the evocative rather than descriptive style") used by the author during his Madrid period. I am not so certain, as I observe many areas and details that are merely sketched out, making it seem rather to be a well-crafted trial piece aimed at securing preliminary approval for a large-scale composition designed to be viewed from below. While it is true that we do not know of the large-format work or fresco that would have been the final version, as it likely was never executed.

To elaborate on the theme proposed for our painting, Tiepolo employed the same mythological symbolism he had used some twenty years earlier on the ceiling of Ca’ Contarini in Venice. Through the twists of history, this Venetian cielo ended up in the Egyptian Embassy in London until 1969, when it was acquired by the National Gallery in London. This was explained to me by Michael Helston, curator of Spanish and late Italian painting at that museum, during his visit to Montserrat in January 1991, whose comments I noted down carefully.

The London composition (292 x 190 cm) sets the scene in the Empyrean heaven, whereas in the Montserrat painting the setting is earthly: a classical plinth with two columns partially draped with a heavy ocher curtain and exotic palm trees in the background landscape, although the central figure is seated on clouds atop a blue sphere. In both compositions the subject is identical, though inverted: old Chronos presents a newborn to the goddess Venus. Is this child in the National Gallery, as is commonly said, the young Aeneas? Or is it a newborn from the Contarini family, as is the case with the young Habsburg in Montserrat? The emblems are identical in both compositions: the scythe and the chariot regarding Chronos, and the cupids and the dove regarding Venus. Both works feature the same model as the protagonist, a remarkably beautiful young woman with the same facial features and hairstyle. We see this same model in other compositions from the painter's Madrid period, such as the Apotheosis of Aeneas, as well as in preliminary sketches, as indicated by Morassi. Nonetheless, differences exist: in the London soffitto, Venus leans on a warrior's helmet in reference to Mars, her husband, and the Cupid in the foreground holds a quiver filled with love arrows; whereas in the Montserrat piece, Venus is assisted by two female figures, likewise nude, the latter holding a warrior's shield featuring the Gorgon in reference to Mars, while the imperial eagle of the Habsburgs stands atop the background pedestal.

Pompeo Molmenti published a pencil, sepia ink, and white wash drawing of the Montserrat painting, preserved in the Cooper Hewitt Museum in New York, which presents minor variations in complementary details not found in our painting. Liliana Barroero casts doubt on the authenticity of this drawing by Tiepolo, considering it rather the work of a copyist. Analyzing the aforementioned American drawing in detail, I observe details that are much more clearly defined than in the Montserrat canvas. A very significant detail is that, on the plinth in the Cooper Hewitt Museum drawing, there is a tabula surmounted by a mask with an almost illegible inscription on the upper line, while on the lower line we can read FECIT AD M. D. G. ("made it to the Greater Glory of God"), which does not appear in the Montserrat painting. The maxim Ad Maiorem Dei Gloriam was the motto of the Society of Jesus, toward which the Spanish King Charles III felt a severe aversion, to the point of banning the order from his realms in 1767. This clearly explains why, in transitioning from the preliminary drawing to an oil sketch—such as the Montserrat painting—he deliberately omitted this inconvenient inscription from a design drawn possibly many years prior, in order to present it to the court or the monarch.
 
Morassi dates the Montserrat Tiepolo to the 1760s and offers the following evaluative judgment: “Excellent work of the late Spanish period”.  

Josep de C. Laplana, Director of the Museum of Montserrat
 
Bibliography
Pompeo Molmenti, G. B. Tiepolo. La sua vita e le sue opere, Milan, Ulrico Hoepli, 1909, p. 223.
Giuseppe Fiocco, Pitture del Settecento italiano nel Portogallo, Rome, Istituto Poligrafico dello Stato, 1940, p. 12, fig. 3.
Antonio Morassi, A complete catalogue of the paintings of G. B. Tiepolo, London, Phaidon, 1962, p. 16, fig. 353.
Anna Pallucchini, L’Opera Completa di Giambattista Tiepolo, Milan, Rizzoli, 1968, no. 287, fig. 134.
Christie’s, 1976/2, no. 53, p. 50-51, fig.
Michael Levey, Giambattista Tiepolo. His Life and Art, Yale University Press, New Haven, 1986, p. 267-269.
Liliana Barroero, Dipinti italiani dal XV al XIX secolo del Museo di Montserrat, Rome, Istituto Poligrafico e Zecca dello Stato. Libreria della Stato, 1992, no. 33, p. 99-101, fig.
Josep de C. Laplana, Les col·leccions de pintura de l’Abadia de Montserrat, Publicacions de l’Abadia de Montserrat, 1999, p. 125, fig.
Roberto Calasso, Il Rosa Tiepolo, Milan, Adelphi Ed., 2006, cover fig., p. 259-261.
Obras Maestras del Museo de Montserrat en BBVA. De Caravaggio a Picasso.  
Exhibition catalog, Madrid, BBVA, no. 24, p. 210-213, fig. (Josep de C. Laplana).
Montserrat. Opere maggiori dell’Abbazia, exhibition catalog, Forte di Bard Editore, 2014, p. 70-71, fig. (Josep de C. Laplana).

 

Tags
Classroom