Artistic and archaeological heritage of the Abbey of Montserrat
Thursday, 19 November 2026

Training of a Hospitaller with His Squire

Museum of Montserrat - EN 30 June 2014


Training of a Hospitaller with His Squire
Fragment of wall painting from San Fructuoso de Bierge, c. 1280-1300
Fresco transferred to a mobile support, 109 x 100 cm.
N.R. 201.232, donation Xavier Busquets, 1990.
 
The paintings of the small Upper Aragonese church of San Fructuoso de Bierge are a very beautiful example of early Linear Gothic south of the Pyrenees. They recount the life of the church's patron, the martyr archbishop of Tarragona Saint Fructuosus, and also include scenes from the life of Saint Nicholas of Myra as well as the martyrdom of Saint John the Evangelist ante Portam Latinam, in Rome. Attentive eyes will detect the hand of two distinct, consecutive masters. The hieratic and inexpressive stances of the first contrast with the narrative, dynamic, gesticulating, lively, and graceful style of the second. The contours reinforced with a thick, dark line and the chromatic vibrancy of reds, blues, and whites lend these paintings a certain resemblance to leaded stained glass.

The small church of San Fructuoso de Bierge, after being burned during the revolutionary events of 1936, was not a parish church and was thus completely abandoned and left out of the official post-war restorations by the "devastated regions" (*regiones devastadas*). Facing the impossibility of the Bishopric of Huesca to undertake such a complex restoration and given the passivity of civil authorities, in 1949 the director of the fledgling Diocesan Museum of Huesca organized a rescue operation to safeguard these paintings, which were in imminent danger of definitive and permanent loss, using a solution that today would be highly debated, but which under those circumstances was the only viable option. They chose to close the small church, as no one could guarantee the preservation of the works in a rural and sparsely populated area. The paintings were detached from the wall, fixed onto canvas, and subsequently mounted on a wooden support. The main and largest section of the ensemble was transferred to the Episcopal and Chapter Museum of Huesca, then being established and inaugurated the following year, while the side paintings were sold to various museums: the Museu Nacional d'Art de Catalunya, The Cloisters in New York, the Art Gallery of Ontario in Toronto, and also to private individuals in order to cover costs and benefit the nascent museum. In this way, although controversial and debated by some, the Bierge paintings were saved, including the small fragment in the Museum of Montserrat under discussion.

The style indisputably links our painting to the Second Master of Bierge; one need only compare it with the scene of the Assassination of Domitian from the Saint John the Evangelist series, which was acquired by an American collector at the time and appeared at auction in Madrid in 1990. The architect Xavier Busquets, donor and benefactor of the Museum of Montserrat, purchased the fragment reviewed here from Josep Gudiol Ricart, an accredited scholar of Gothic art, who managed the safeguard operation of these paintings alongside his brother Ramon, who restored them magnificently despite the inherent difficulty and complexity of the process.

The theme of weapon training between a Hospitaller knight and his squire has no parallel in Aragonese or Catalan painting. This unusual depiction in this location could be explained by Bierge's proximity to Monzón, which had recently passed from the newly suppressed Order of the Temple to the Hospitallers of Saint John of Jerusalem, whose habit differed only in that their cross was white while that of the Templars was red. The theme of a knight's weapons training was—already in the sermons of Saint Bernard—a moral example urged to strengthen virtues against vices and indolence. These might be the reasons for including this scene among the paintings at Bierge.  

Josep de C. Laplana, Director of the Museum of Montserrat
  
Bibliography
 
- Josep Gudiol Cunill, La pintura mig-eval catalana, vol. II, Els trecentistes. Segona part. Barcelona, S. Babra, 1927, p. 507-508, 521-523.
- Chandler Rathfon Post, A History of Spanish Painting, Harvard University Press, vol. II,  1930, p. 61-63.
- Juan Antonio Gaya Nuño, La pintura española fuera de España (Historia y catálogo), Madrid, Espasa-Calpe, 1958, p. 88.
- Josep Gudiol Ricart, Pintura medieval en Aragón, Zaragoza, Inst. Fernando el Católico, 1971, p. 19, 27-28.
- Edmund Peel & Asociados, Pintura Antigua y del siglo XIX, Auction, Madrid, 30-X-1990, **2.
- Signos. Arte y Cultura en el Alto Aragón Medieval, Exhibition catalog, Jaca-Huesca, June-September, 1993, p. 352 (Mª Carmen Lacarra).
- Joan Fuguet i Sans, “Consideracions sobre l’ús de la creu en l’Orde del Temple”, El temps sota control. Homenatge a F. Xavier Ricomà Vendrell. Diputació de Tarragona, 1997, p. 295-308.
- Montserrat. Opere maggiori dell’Abbazia, exhibition catalog, Forte di Bard Editore, 2014, p. 36-37. fig. (Josep de C. Laplana).

 

Tags
Classroom