

Domenico Corvi
(Viterbo, 1721 – Rome, 1803)
Lamentations over the Body of Hector
1785
Oil on canvas, 159 x 220 cm.
N.R. 200.181. Acquired in Rome in 1919.
Among the group of paintings Abbot Marcet purchased in Rome and Naples during his trip in May 1919 was this painting. An inscription on the back of the canvas indicates the status under which it was acquired from the antique dealer and art merchant Baldasare Belisario (Salita di San Sebastianello, Piazza di Spagna): “Ecole français (sic) / Mort de Germanicus / David / P. / Gall. Fesch / R”. We have records of the difficulties in obtaining export permits for artworks, which became increasingly hard to secure following the war. Fr. Ubach, acting as Montserrat's agent in these matters, wrote to Abbot Marcet on August 7 of that same year: “All the blame for the delay lies with that painting representing the death of Germanicus, which they did not want to let out and which the Museum Directorate wanted to keep. Many petitions were required to achieve it” (AAMt). This initial attribution of the painting to Jacques-Louis David (1748–1825) has no basis other than this artist's frequency in depicting themes from the Iliad, such as Andromache Mourning Hector—the same subject as our painting—which David presented at the Paris Salon of 1783; however, David's composition, now at the École Nationale Supérieure des Beaux-Arts, consists of only three figures and bears no relation to ours. On the other hand, it is interesting to note that the Roman board tasked with issuing the export permit for our painting did not buy the attribution, despite the inscription on the canvas, suspecting instead that it was an Italian painting of potential interest to the Capitoline Museum.
In September 1919, the work under study arrived at Montserrat alongside a stock of around twenty paintings, recorded in the Monastery's chronicle and later in its culture journal as follows: “The Death of Germanicus (185 x 245 cm.) by David, original, French school”. Although ten years later this attribution appeared more than suspicious, it was not changed. Fr. Gusi's inventories simply noted: “school of L. David”. The fact that it was not a religious painting and featured a reclining, nude male body as its central subject led to the painting not being placed in a highly visible area inside the monastery; as a result, scholars visiting the Montserrat Art Gallery did not see it or take it into consideration.
As in many other instances, the first to study and be surprised by the discovery of this painting was Liliana Barroero, who could not resist immediately communicating her find to her Italian colleagues in a short monographic article in 1984, eight years before publishing her book on Italian paintings at Montserrat. Upon viewing the photographs sent to her, Barroero instantly linked our canvas with the detailed description published by Giuseppe Antonio Guattani, perpetual secretary of the Accademia di S. Luca in Rome, in 1785, when Domenico Corvi, Viterbese e Accademico di San Luca, completed and presented this painting. Its subject was by no means the Death of Germanicus, but another theme also quite common in Neoclassical painting: the Lamentations over the Body of Hector. Unfortunately, Guattani does not state who commissioned the work or its destination. In any case, the inscription on the back of the Montserrat canvas suggests it had belonged to the Galleria Fesch—that is, the collection of Cardinal Joseph Fesch (Ajaccio, 1762 – Rome, 1839), uncle of Napoleon, created cardinal in 1802 and French ambassador to the Holy See. Following Napoleon's fall, Pius VII welcomed him to Rome, where he devoted himself almost exclusively to promoting science and the arts, making his painting collection famous across Europe. Nevertheless, our painting does not appear in the sale catalogs of the prestigious Fesch collection; but this proves nothing more than what it says: it could have left the collection prior to the sale, or the inscription on the back might simply have been a false lead to facilitate its sale.
Liliana Barroero also discovered the existence of an identical version of the same dimensions as the Montserrat canvas at the Camuccini Palace in Cantalupo, in the Sabina region, which, like other works from the same collection, went up for auction in Rome in November 2006. However, comparing the Camuccini canvas with the Montserrat one, it is immediately apparent that the former is not fully finished, lacking the final modeling and atmosphere present in the Montserrat painting. It was likely a version the artist kept in his studio and never fully completed. Barroero connects this fact convincing with Luigi Lanzi's account, which informs us that the Neoclassical painter Vincenzo Camuccini (1773–1844), owner of the palace and former pupil of Corvi, bought various paintings and drawings from the widow upon the admired master's death. Among these was the unfinished version of the Montserrat painting, listed as Achille presso il cadavere di Patroclo.
Guattani, in his report on the painting, provides a detailed description based on Book 24 of the Iliad. Priam orders the body of Hector, the fallen hero recovered by Achilles, to be displayed before the Trojans. The setting is a hall in the royal palace of Troy, decorated with funerary drapes and lit exclusively by three lamps with burning torches and two braziers containing hot embers to burn incense. Hector's naked body, crowned with laurel, rests on a bed covered with a golden silk quilt, with his armor placed at his feet as trophies. His heartbroken wife, Andromache, lifts his head in a gesture to kiss him. Helen, the cause of the Trojan War, stands motionless at the foot of the funerary couch observing the scene impassively, while Cassandra, Hector's sister, who had predicted the catastrophe, is consumed by tears and looks at Helen with a disapproving gesture. The hero's younger brothers look on and weep from the head of the bed. The nurse embraces Astyanax, Hector's young son. Priam, the father, contemplates the hero's body with immense grief for not having heeded Cassandra's warning. Behind him, two Trojan warriors plot revenge. In the background to the right, Hecuba, the mother, supported by her handmaidens, enters the scene tragically. The atmosphere is dense, toned with a golden, matte light emanating from the braziers, muting even the bright colors. The tragedy is recounted with the composure, serenity, and austere majesty characteristic of Neoclassicism.
Our painting is, almost certainly, a pendant to another of the same size and similar composition titled Sacrifice of Polyxena, located at the Museo Civico in Viterbo. Curiously, this Viterbo painting did not generate reports or descriptions at the time like the Montserrat canvas did, yet both works fully merit the praise Guattani bestowed upon the Montserrat piece regarding its “tenerezza di colorito” (tenderness of coloring) and its composition based on a gentle, undulating geometry “senza tagliarne per così dire la composizione”. Liliana Barroero considers this work by Corvi “come uno dei più alti raggiungimenti poetici non solo all’interno del catalogo dell’artista viterbese, ma in tutto il lungo corso del settecento pittorico romano” (as one of the highest poetic achievements not only within the catalog of the Viterbo artist, but in the entire long course of 18th-century Roman painting).
Josep de C. Laplana, Director of the Museum of Montserrat
Bibliography
Giuseppe Antonio Guattani, “Il Signor Domenico Corvi”, Memorie per le Belle Arti, I, June 1785, pp. 87-88; Giornale delle Belle Arti, II, 25-VI-1785, p. 193-194.
Luigi Lanzi, Storia pittorica della Italia. Dal Risorgimento delle Belle Arti fin presso al fine del XVIII secolo, Milan, Società Classici Italiani, vol. II, 1824, p. 286.
George, Catalogue des tableaux composant la galérie de feu de Son Éminence le Cardinal Fesch,
Analecta Montserratensia, III, 1919, p. 389.
Liliana Barroero, “Il compianto sul corpo di Ettore, di Domenico Corvi”, Paragone, no. 417, Nov, 1984, p. 66-71, fig.
Liliana Barroero, Dipinti italiani dal XV al XIX secolo del Museo di Montserrat, Rome, Istituto Poligrafico e Zecca dello Stato. Libreria della Stato, 1992, no. 40, p. 117-118, color fig.
Josep de C. Laplana, Les col·leccions de pintura de l’Abadia de Montserrat, Publicacions de l’Abadia de Montserrat, 1999, p. 42, 48, 127, color fig.


Les cookies són importants per a tu, influeixen en la teva experiència de navegació, ens ajuden a protegir la teva privacitat i permeten realitzar les peticions que ens sol·licitis a través de la web. Utilitzem cookies pròpies i de tercers per analitzar els nostres serveis i mostrar-te publicitat relacionada com les teves preferències en base a un perfil elaborat amb els teus hàbits de navegació. Pots "Acceptar" o "Rebutjar" aquelles cookies que no siguin tècniques, així com també configurar les teves preferències prement "Configurar Cookies". Per a més informació, consulta la nostra Política de Cookies.