

Antoni Viladomat
(Barcelona, 1678 – 1755)
Jesus Among the Doctors of the Law
c. 1720-1750
Oil on canvas, 105 x 156 cm.
N.R. 200.016. Donation of Canon Iglésias, 1827.
This painting was part of the large donation made by Canon Iglésias, from Santa Anna of Barcelona, which arrived at Montserrat in 1827. It is remarkable and surprising that it has remained at Montserrat to this day, since with the confiscation and suppression of the monastery in 1835, the finest and largest portion of Canon Iglésias's paintings was confiscated and dispersed into private hands, and this painting under study must have been among the best.
The inventories of Fr. Gusi compiled around 1930 and 1931 already record it as coming from the Iglésias donation and attribute it, without hesitation or reservation, to the Barcelona painter Antoni Viladomat, the finest of his era in Barcelona and Catalonia. The most comprehensive study of this work and of Viladomat's entire painted oeuvre is undoubtedly that of Dr. Francesc Miralpeix, which was the subject of his doctoral thesis. This entry is based on Miralpeix's contributions, which I summarize while also supplementing and clarifying on certain points.
Starting with Rafael Benet's 1947 monograph, which reproduces the image of our painting, almost all studies on Viladomat include the Montserrat canvas. However, the scholar who studied and highlighted the unique value of this piece was Dr. Santiago Alcolea Gil, a specialist in 18th-century Barcelona painting. He was the first to connect our painting with that Disputation of Jesus with the Doctors of the Law in the Temple, which Jaime Villanueva saw in the cell of the Prior of the Convent of Sant Agustí in Barcelona, alongside four other paintings, all depicting scenes from the life of Jesus, and all by Antoni Viladomat. Villanueva's journey to Barcelona took place in 1805, and on October 21, 1809, as explained by the Oratorian Fr. Raimon Ferrer, who was the spontaneous and accurate chronicler of Napoleonic-occupied Barcelona, the Board tasked with executing government orders went to seize the Convent of Sant Agustí. In a footnote, the chronicler reports that a few weeks later he saw the books and paintings of the Prior of Sant Agustí being sold at an auction on the Rambla. It is more than likely that Canon Iglésias, an inveterate collector, aware of the events and a neighbor of the Rambla, did not let the opportunity pass and purchased the painting discussed here, which eventually arrived with his art collection at Montserrat.
When painting medium-format canvases, Viladomat often articulates his compositions using half-length figures, thereby concentrating the viewer's attention on facial expressions. He almost always structures the composition in a very clear and simple manner using intersecting diagonals at the center, at a time when Baroque fashion was beginning to propose more complex compositional schemes and more theatrical gestures. Viladomat seeks simplicity and an easy, direct reading of the scene above all else, avoiding unnecessary accessories and encouraging admiring, devout contemplation without gimmicks or curious surprises. He employs dark backgrounds and earthy tones characteristic of 17th-century painting, which still preserved a degree of chiaroscuro.
Naturally, the focal point of our painting is the figure of the Child, seated magisterially in an armchair, looking toward the viewer and accompanying his discourse with expressive hand gestures. To the right and left we see the doctors of the Law, all in profile and gazing fixedly at the wise Child, confronting the boy's discourse with the prophecies of the sacred books. The Child commands authority through his composure and poise, while the doctors—the one on the left dressed in velvet and damask as if holding a rank superior to the others—display admiration and astonishment. Mary and Joseph, deprived of prominence, observe the scene discreetly in the background. Miralpeix emphasizes that behind the composition and staging of this painting lie models and solutions highly typical of 17th-century Neapolitan painting.
Josep de C. Laplana, Director of the Museum of Montserrat
Bibliography
- Jaime Villanueva, Viage literario a las Iglesias de España, XVIII, Viage a Barcelona, Madrid, Academia de la Historia, 1851, p. 172-175.
- Raimon Ferrer, Barcelona Cautiva, o sea diario exacto de lo ocurrido en la misma ciudad mientras la oprimieron los franceses, vol. IV. Barcelona, Brusi, 1817, p. 172-175.
- Rafael Benet, Viladomat, Barcelona, Ed. Ibèria, 1947, pl. 11.
- Frederic-Pau Verrié, Montserrat, Madrid, Plus-Ultra, ca. 1950, p. 110, fig. (Los monumentos cardinales de España – IX).
- L’Art Català, Barcelona, Ed. Aymà, vol. II, 1961, p. 108, fig. (text by Rafael Benet).
- Santiago Alcolea, “La pintura barcelonesa en el siglo XVIII. Diccionario biográfico”, Anales y Boletín de los Museos de Arte de Barcelona, XV, 1961-1962, p. 202, fig. 42.
- Santiago Alcolea, Viladomat, Mataró, Museu Comarcal del Maresme i Museu Arxiu de Santa Maria, 1990, p. 116-117, 272, fig.
- Santiago Alcolea, Antonio Viladomat, Barcelona, Ed. Labor, 1992, p. 32 and 37 (Gent Nostra, 96).
- Josep de C. Laplana, Les col·leccions de pintura de l’Abadia de Montserrat, Publicacions de l’Abadia de Montserrat, 1999, p. 17-21.
- Francesc Miralpeix, Antoni Viladomat i Manalt, 1678- 1755. Vida i obra, Girona, Museu d’Art de Girona, 2014, p. 160, cat. 140.
Les cookies són importants per a tu, influeixen en la teva experiència de navegació, ens ajuden a protegir la teva privacitat i permeten realitzar les peticions que ens sol·licitis a través de la web. Utilitzem cookies pròpies i de tercers per analitzar els nostres serveis i mostrar-te publicitat relacionada com les teves preferències en base a un perfil elaborat amb els teus hàbits de navegació. Pots "Acceptar" o "Rebutjar" aquelles cookies que no siguin tècniques, així com també configurar les teves preferències prement "Configurar Cookies". Per a més informació, consulta la nostra Política de Cookies.