
Master of the Annunciation to the Shepherds (Joan Do?)
Active in Naples between 1620 – c. 1650.
Martyrdom of Saint Placidus and Companions
c. 1625-1635
Oil on canvas, 175 x 257 cm.
N.R. 200.169. Acquired in Rome from a Neapolitan collection in 1915.
In October 1915, art dealer Giuseppe Gonella offered the Monastery of Montserrat the purchase for 3,000 lire of a painting owned by a Neapolitan family in severe financial distress, calling it right from the start "a San Plácido by Ribera," thus attributing it without hesitation to José de Ribera,
lo Spagnoletto. Abbot Marcet acquired it during his trip to Rome and Naples in November of that year, and the painting arrived at Montserrat in mid-February 1916. Immediately, the Monastery's popular magazine highlighted it as the most important piece from the latest shipment of Italian artworks, and the following year Montserrat's culture journal published its photograph with the attribution to Ribera, stating: "It is a truly authentic work, guaranteed not only by the well-defined characteristics of the master, but also by the signature found in the darkness of one of the corners." In truth, we have never seen this signature, and it does not appear in any old photograph.
Following his visit to Montserrat to view the Art Gallery, Dr. August Mayer wrote to Fr. Gusi on January 31, 1929, with categorical firmness: "The Martyrdom of St. Placidus has nothing to do with Ribera." Although this painting had always occupied prominent locations inside the Monastery, when the time came to organize the new Museum of Montserrat, it was excluded. Beyond the existing doubts regarding its authorship, it was considered overly crowded with figures and difficult to read. Still, it continued to be attributed to Ribera as no alternative hypothesis emerged. When Dr. José Milicua and Dr. Giovanni Previtali visited Montserrat's
quadreria in September 1976, they placed this painting within the Neapolitan Francanzano circle. It should be noted that while neither of these attributions to Ribera or Francanzano was entirely precise, neither was far-fetched, as neither erred in period or milieu: Naples, second or third decade of the 17th century.
Inexplicably, this painting went unnoticed by Pérez Sánchez when he visited Montserrat to gather material for his doctoral thesis on 17th-century Italian painting in Spain. As in many other cases, the first to study our canvas with academic rigor was Liliana Barroero, who decisively attributed it to the anonymous artist known in scholarly circles as the "Master of the Annunciation to the Shepherds." He is so named after his emblematic painting
Annuncio ai Pastori (180 x 261.5 cm) in the Capodimonte Museum in Naples, and also after the homonymous canvas in the Birmingham Museum, where it was once listed as a work by Velázquez.
The exhibition of Neapolitan painting held in London (1982), Paris (1983), Naples (1984–1985), and Madrid (1985) included several works by the Master of the Annunciation to the Shepherds, prompting and reactivating research into other canvases by the same painter scattered across various museums under different attributions. From these reassessments emerged a fairly substantial and coherent
corpus of about a dozen works attributable to this same hand. Professor Maurizio Marini had previously suggested that the anonymous
"Maestro dell’Annuncio ai Pastori" might be the Valencian artist Joan Do, active in Naples at that time as a disciple and collaborator of José de Ribera—a hypothesis that, while not fully proven, continues to gain support. Joan Do was born in Xàtiva around 1604 and died in Naples in 1656 during the plague. By 1626 he was already established in the capital of Campania, as he married a sister of the painter Pacecco di Rosa, with Neapolitan painters Filippo Vitale, Battistello Caracciolo, and José de Ribera serving as witnesses at the ceremony, illustrating the network of friendships and influences in which Joan Do moved. He worked in the studio of his compatriot José de Ribera, first as an assistant and later as a business partner.
His painting, generally dark and dense, retains a trace of Caravaggism. His colors are greasy and grainy, though over time he adopted a brighter palette. His figures are drawn from the common people—rugged, yet vigorous and expressive.
Upon studying our
Martyrdom of Saint Placidus and Companions, Maurizio Marini confirmed Barroero's attribution, noting that it required appropriate restoration as he discerned it to be one of Joan Do's finest works. In her study, Liliana Barroero highlights the resemblance between the facial features in our painting and those in the
Return of the Prodigal Son at Capodimonte in Naples. The postures and arrangement of the figures in our canvas align perfectly with the
Annuncio ai Pastori, also at Capodimonte.
Saint Placidus is a beloved and revered saint, particularly within the Benedictine Order, having been received as a child by Saint Benedict himself. This leads us to consider a probable Benedictine origin for the commission of this painting. The martyrdom of this saint is entirely legendary, inspired by the 12th-century
Passio Sancti Placidi falsely attributed to Gordian. According to this text, Placidus founded a Benedictine monastery in Messina where he served as abbot; during a raid on Sicily, Saracens beheaded Abbot Saint Placidus and his monks. This is a crude anachronism, as Saint Benedict died as an elderly man around 545, his first disciples could not have survived him by more than 30 years, and Muhammad would barely have been born at that time. But no matter! The literary subject was real and inspired numerous artworks across the Benedictine world.
The center of the composition features the kneeling saint, dressed in the black Benedictine cowl with hands crossed over his chest, his head bowed as he awaits the fatal blow from a barbarian, half-naked executioner who lunges at the victim with raised saber. Another monk lies on the ground gesticulating while another executioner attempts to plunge a dagger into him, and in the corner we see another already dead. This tragic right side finds its explanation on the left, where we see the true instigators: a figure dressed as an Ottoman with a crescent-crowned turban, seated on a Turkish carpet, giving the order for the execution while listening to the malicious whisperings of a pagan priest with slicked-back hair and a Chinese pigtail.
Liliana Barroero notes that the position of these two figures is remarkably similar,
“quasi sovrapponibile”, to Jacob Coelemans's print
Jacob Meeting Rachel; however, there is no need to assume an influence of the printmaker on the painter, but rather the reverse: Coelemans (Antwerp, 1654 – Aix-en-Provence, 1735) produced his engraving based on the work of the Master of the Annunciation to the Shepherds, who was by no means an insignificant painter.
Josep de C. Laplana, Director of the Museum of Montserrat
Bibliography
* Analecta Montserratensia, I, 1917, p. 339, fig.
* Enciclopedia Universal Espasa-Calpe, vol. 45, Barcelona, 1921, s/v. Plácido (San), p. 254-255, fig.
* Maurizio Marini, Pittori a Napoli , 1610 – 1656: contributi e schede, Rome, Bulzoni editori, 1974, p. 103.
* Pintura Napolitana, de Caravaggio a Giordano, exhibition catalog, Museo del Prado, Palacio de Villahermosa, Oct-Dec, 1985.
* Liliana Barroero, “Schede seicentesche: Fignolio, Vaccaro, Vanni e il Maestro degli Annunci”, Prospettiva, IV-1989 – X-1990, no. 57-60, vol. II, p. 218, fig.
* Liliana Barroero, Dipinti italiani dal XV al XIX secolo del Museo di Montserrat, Rome, Istituto Poligrafico e Zecca dello Stato. Libreria della Stato, 1992, p. 123, color fig.
* Josep de C. Laplana, Montserrat, 1000 anys d’art i història, Manresa, Angle Editorial, 1998, p. 123, color fig.
* Josep de C. Laplana, Les col·leccions de pintura de l’Abadia de Montserrat, Publicacions de l’Abadia de Montserrat, 1999, p. 31, 34, color fig.
* Giuseppe De Vito, “Juan Dò riconfermato”, Ricerche sul’600 napoletano. Saggi e documenti, 2003-2004, p. 85-91.


