


Pedro Berruguete
(Paredes de Nava, Palencia, 1450 – Madrid, 1503)
Birth of the Virgin
Dormition of the Virgin
c. 1485 – 1490.
Oil and gold leaf on panel, 128 x 95 cm.
N. R. 200.302 and 200.301, acquired in Madrid, 1948.
The first reliable news we have regarding these two panels dates back to their appearance in the art market on December 9, 1925, at the American Art Galleries in New York, as part of a lot of “five important paintings by Pedro Berruguete”, which belonged to the Madrid antique dealer Raimundo Ruiz. Today, this figure is considered the great Spanish pioneer of the international antique trade. Of these “five important paintings,” only two panels were sold; the other three, including the two now housed in the Museum of Montserrat, returned to Madrid. Eager to find a suitable buyer, Raimundo and his brother Luis Ruiz exhibited these pieces alongside several others—all by Berruguete—in the Spanish Art Pavilion at the Barcelona International Exposition in 1928, as seen in the official catalog compiled by Professor Gómez Moreno. The first scholarly monograph on Berruguete and his work, written by Láinez Alcalá in 1935 and reprinted in 1943, collected and expanded the information on Raimundo Ruiz's panels and published good photographs. Chandler R. Post followed the trail of these panels and, in Volume IX of his monumental work, put forward the hypothesis of a grand altarpiece dedicated to the Virgin of unknown provenance.
Under these circumstances, the Abbot of Montserrat, Aureli M. Escarré, received word that these exquisite paintings by Berruguete were for sale in Madrid, and spared no effort until he gathered from his numerous acquaintances the funds required to acquire the two pieces currently displayed at the Museum of Montserrat. The transaction and the arrival of the two panels at Montserrat date to 1948. From that moment on, guidebooks and monograph studies on Montserrat cited and reproduced these works by Berruguete as among the Abbey's most notable heritage. In 1962, they left the monastery interior to be permanently exhibited in the Museum of Montserrat. Yet despite everything, scholars and specialists from the capital overlooked these developments and continued to cite the panels as belonging to the antique dealer or from an unknown location, relying solely on Gómez Moreno's text. The Spanish academic world finally “discovered” Montserrat's Berruguetes when Young published his 1975 study on the panel of Solomon, which Harry Guggenheim had acquired at the aforementioned 1925 New York auction. Young cited and reproduced the Montserrat panels as components of the same altarpiece, proposing a hypothetical reconstruction in his article.
Pedro Berruguete was the father of the famous Castilian sculptor Alonso Berruguete (1490–1555) and is considered the chief propagator of Renaissance forms in Castilian painting. He trained in the circle of Justus of Ghent (c. 1435 – c. 1480) in the stylistic concepts of Flemish painting. Solid, though not undeniable, evidence suggests that in 1477 he traveled to Italy and worked at the Ducal Palace of Urbino, where he produced a series of portraits for the studiolo, such as that of Sixtus IV, now in the Louvre, and those of Federico da Montefeltro with his son Guidobaldo. In Spain, he worked for the cathedrals of Toledo and Ávila; there, he received the commission from the Inquisitor Torquemada to paint the main altarpiece for the Dominican convent of Santo Tomás. The final years of his life were spent in his hometown, where he continued painting altarpieces for rural churches, most of which are now fragmented, as is the case with our two panels.
Berruguete's painting merges Flemish and Italian forms in an eclectic manner, integrating them into a highly vigorous realism of Castilian root. He creates real space through perspective and light as was done in Italy, placing the figures beautifully within a scenic conception closer to Gothic naturalism than to Renaissance idealism, and introducing—much like the Flemish masters—complementary everyday elements that lend charm and verisimilitude to the narrative.
The panel of the Birth of the Virgin depicts the endearing moment of placing the newborn child into her mother's arms, once she has been washed and warmed, to receive her first kiss. Berruguete presents the mother Anne, bare-chested as was customary, in a very comfortable bed with a canopy and gold-brocade green drapery. The prominent figure in the left foreground, set apart by her stance and her luxurious dress distinct from those of the other women, may evoke a woman related to the patron acting as a relative or close friend of Anne, bringing her the traditional chicken broth given to women in childbed. The painter enlivens the scene by placing the bedchamber adjacent to the entrance porch, where we see four matrons in a circumspect attitude, and in the background, a city with prominent civic buildings.
While the Birth of the Virgin allows us to witness the tender moment of welcoming the newborn, the panel of the Dormition of the Virgin illustrates the ideal of a good death desired by every faithful Christian, portrayed in the scene of the Mother of God's passing surrounded by the apostles. It must also be considered that the period when Berruguete painted this scene coincided with the height of paraliturgical theatrical performances in cathedrals regarding the Dormition of the Virgin celebrated on August 15. Berruguete arranges the scene in an interior with Italian Renaissance architecture and luxurious tiled flooring. It is not a bedroom but a grand hall, functioning as a stage where the stagehand has placed the large bed upon which the Virgin lies in prayer. This bed is not a fixed piece of furniture; rather, it takes the form of a catafalque, like those used in churches for mystery plays of the Assumption or like the litter where the recumbent image of the deceased Virgin was placed for veneration. The canopy is supported from the ceiling by a system of ropes. It is opulent, featuring a Moorish-decorated border with gold tassels, a gold brocade backing, and heavy, solemn curtains, likely of green Flemish velvet. The knot tying the central section of the drapery is identical to the one on the bed in the Birth panel.
The Virgin's bed attire—nightgown and headscarf—is entirely white. Premeditately, the painter has excluded any trace of suffering from the face of the Mother of God, making it truly a "Dormition." The figure attending to the Virgin and holding her arm is undoubtedly Saint Peter; the figure of John the Evangelist is the beardless apostle kneeling on the step of the catafalque on the other side of the Virgin. The other apostles pray or read the commendation of the soul, as was customary during the final moments of a devout Christian. The first apostle on the right dressed entirely in gold brocade could well be Saint James, given the Palentian locale where this altarpiece was likely painted. Notable is the slanted manner of attaching the halo of sanctity to the heads of some apostles, resembling a plate. The candleless bronze candlestick in the foreground is also of great interest, documenting with precision the peculiar shape of this object.
This entire panel suffered fairly heavy repainting during the restoration prior to its commercial sale in the 1920s, which was retained in subsequent restorations (Ramon Gudiol in 1971, and in 2002 prior to the retrospective exhibition in Paredes de Nava). In the Dormition panel, the gold decoration on the bedspread has completely disappeared, and clumsy repainting by a restorer is very evident in the beards of most of the apostles on the right. While these touch-ups certainly add no merit to the work, they do not severely hinder its correct interpretation.
Josep de C. Laplana, Director of the Museum of Montserrat
Bibliography
- Manuel Gómez Moreno, El Arte en España. Exposición Internacional de Barcelona, 1929, Barcelona, Impr. Subirana, 1929, p. 571, no. 3221 and p. 604, fig.
- Rafael Láinez Alcalá, Pedro Berruguete, pintor de Castilla. Ensayo crítico biográfico, Madrid, Espasa-Calpe, 1935, p. 53, fig. 60 and 62.
- Chandler Rathfon Post, A History of Spanish Painting, Harvard University Press, vol IX, 1947, part 1, p. 114.
- Frederic-Pau Verrié, Montserrat, Madrid, Plus-Ultra, ca. 1950, p. 104-105, fig.
- José Camón Aznar, La pintura española del siglo XVI, Madrid, Espasa-Calpe, 1970 (Summa Artis – XXIV), p. 165, fig. 156.
- Eric Young, “A rediscovered Painting by Pedro Berruguete and Its Companion Panels”, The Art Bulletin, 57, December, 1975, p. 473-475.
- Josep de C. Laplana, Montserrat, 1000 anys d’art i història, Manresa, Angle Editorial, 1998, p. 88, fig.
- Josep de C. Laplana, Les col·leccions de pintura de l’Abadia de Montserrat, Publicacions de l’Abadia de Montserrat, 1999, p. 63, 114, fig.
- Pilar Silva Maroto, Pedro Berruguete, Salamanca, Junta de Castilla y León, 2001, p. 197-198, 253-254.
- Pilar Silva Maroto et alii, Pedro Berruguete, el primer pintor renacentista de la Corona de Castilla, Exhibition catalog, Junta de Castilla y León in Paredes de Nava (Palencia), April 4 – June 8, 2003, p. 126-129, fig.
- Santiago Alcolea Blanch, in Obras Maestras del Museo de Montserrat en BBVA. De Caravaggio a Picasso. Exhibition catalog, Palacio del Marqués de Salamanca, BBVA, Madrid, October 9 to December 7, 2008, p. 80-83, fig.
- Josep de C. Laplana, Montserrat. Opere maggiori dell’Abbazia, exhibition catalog, Forte di Bard Editore, 2014, p. 40, fig.
Les cookies són importants per a tu, influeixen en la teva experiència de navegació, ens ajuden a protegir la teva privacitat i permeten realitzar les peticions que ens sol·licitis a través de la web. Utilitzem cookies pròpies i de tercers per analitzar els nostres serveis i mostrar-te publicitat relacionada com les teves preferències en base a un perfil elaborat amb els teus hàbits de navegació. Pots "Acceptar" o "Rebutjar" aquelles cookies que no siguin tècniques, així com també configurar les teves preferències prement "Configurar Cookies". Per a més informació, consulta la nostra Política de Cookies.