Artistic and archaeological heritage of the Abbey of Montserrat
Thursday, 19 November 2026

Jesus Carrying the Cross, by Cotignola

Museum of Montserrat - EN 18 September 2015


GIROLAMO MARCHESI DA COTIGNOLA or a follower
(Cotignola, c. 1471 – Rome, 1540/1550).
Jesus Carrying the Cross
c. 1540.
Oil on panel, 42 x 38 cm
N. R. 200.326, acquired in Rome, 1919

This is a high-quality painting that arrived at Montserrat on September 7, 1918, as an anonymous work. Fr. Bonaventura Ubach, acting in Rome as the delegate of the Abbot of Montserrat for the acquisition of paintings, saw this artwork in March of that year at the premises of art dealer Giuseppe Gonella and agreed on its purchase. The Italian origin of this work is, therefore, an unquestionable fact. The cultural journal published by the Monastery of Montserrat reproduced it on a full page, despite it carrying no attribution to a famous painter, as was customary at the time.

In 1943, the Marquess of Lozoya, then Director General of Fine Arts and considered the foremost authority on Hispanic art, remarked during one of his visits to Montserrat that this panel appeared to him to be an authentic work by Bartolomé Bermejo, the itinerant Andalusian painter who also worked in Barcelona. Given that it was an unattributed painting and considering the high authority of the Marquess of Lozoya, his spontaneous opinion was initially accepted as an oracle. However, over time, as it was contrasted with the opinions of other scholars who rejected this claim, the inventories of Montserrat's painting collection from the 1940s and 1950s listed the panel Jesus Carrying the Cross as an attributed work to Bermejo, or more tersely as "Spanish school." Only when including this panel in the new Museum of Montserrat in 1963 was its Italian origin recalled, categorizing it as "Roman School of the mid-16th century."

This panel, despite its artistic refinement, has still never been thoroughly studied. The frame is as old as the painting and highly characteristic of the period. The support consists of three glued wooden panels with a convex surface that tend to shift and damage the paint along the joints. Likely before exhibiting it at the Museum of Montserrat in 1963, it was restored and the wooden support was reinforced with a very rigid screwed subframe, which caused new tensions and pigment flaking. There are also some retouchings in the background and corners, but fortunately, the figure of Christ remains intact, allowing for a clear reading of the original execution.

In the 1990s, Professor Liliana Barroero from Sapienza University of Rome, during her comprehensive study of Italian paintings in the Museum of Montserrat, set this panel aside upon seeing its "Roman School" attribution. Examining the back of the painting and the joint of the panels, it becomes evident that the work is ancient and not a 19th-century forgery, but an authentic work by an unknown 16th-century Italian artist. This is the stance the Museum has always maintained. In the summer of 2008, Professor Massimo Pulini from the Academy of Fine Arts of Bologna, a highly regarded authority on Bolognese painting and its circle, visited the reserve collection of the Museum of Montserrat. Pulini was familiar with Barroero's work and carefully inspected our panel from both front and back. At first glance, he affirmed that the work was authentic, 16th century, and belonged to the Bolognese circle, in which he specialized. He suggested the name of Girolamo Marchesi da Cotignola or a follower as the author of this panel, which he valued highly.

Pulini's opinion is authoritative but not definitive. It is a first impression, yet it offers a leads to undertake a thorough investigation that has not yet been carried out. Indeed, the two modern monographs published on Girolamo da Cotignola with abundant illustrations show similarities with the Montserrat panel, though they do not provide conclusive proof. This artist worked successively in Bologna, Rimini, Naples, and Rome, where our artwork was acquired. However, in my view, the Montserrat panel is much more vigorous than what I have seen of this author; it possesses a refinement of details and an intensity I have not found in any other. A comparison between the Montserrat panel and other Cristo portacroce works by Girolamo da Cotignola—the one in the Galleria Spada in Rome and the one in the Musée du Petit Palais in Avignon—reveals notable differences in execution, though all are rendered according to the same pattern and obey the same concept. Perhaps the Montserrat panel belongs to the author's late Roman period, or perhaps it is the work of a highly skilled follower of master Girolamo da Cotignola. Be that as it may, there is a clear lead to follow in researching this Italian Cinquecento panel.

Josep de C. Laplana, Director of the Museum of Montserrat 

 

Bibliography

  • Archive Notes of the Museum of Montserrat
  • Analecta Montserratensia, II, 1918, p. 452, fig.
  • Barroero, Liliana, Dipinti italiani dal XV al XIX secolo del Museo di Montserrat, Rome.
  • Donati, Andrea, Girolamo Marchesi da Cotignola, Republic of San Marino, Asset Banca, 2007.
  • Zama, Raffaella, Girolamo Marchesi da Cotignola, pittore, Rome: Luisé editore, 2007.

 

Tags
Classroom